Final Appeal qoop

[Concobe (OP)]

State your full Minecraft username: qoop
New Name: Pot4Me
State the punishment you recieved: Perm Ban
State what you were likely doing that got you banned/punished: Being a Douche
State what you would like to happen to your case and why (pardoned/forgiven/etc):
Listen i don't think i will be unbanned, but this last appeal was worth a shot. I just want to play again for two main reasons i would like to help Eminem with some projects and i dont want to be banned from a server i have spent so much time and also donated on. I know almost all the staff have a bad view on me but if you are willing to give me one more chance i would not blow it. It was really a mistake for me to make Livid feel bad and i apologize for that livid i hope you can forgive me but i understand if you can't. To all the staff i've ever treated   like crap i hope you can forgive me as well. I hope to play again but it's all up to you guys. Then if not i guess this is my final goodbye to VillageCraft it's been some great times. Also i know i didnt state much if what i did to Livid but since i already wrote an appeal one or two times most of you already know. (At least i think you do)

[Shensley]

no.   

[Witchdoctor1]

no.   

Rule: unless you are appealing a punishment, please don't post in someone else's appeal unless you have evidence or information that would make your intervention worthwhile. We don't need comments or opinions, unless we ask for them. Evidence and information is okay. Intervening with irrelevant posts that are not important to the appeal may result in an immediate forum temporary ban. Please, though, post useful information, observations, and interpretations if they add to the thread.

[/quote]

[Witchdoctor1]

Reviewing your ban, it seems as if you are under a permaban for multiple offenses. Furthermore, the ban is six months old. I doubt that is enough time to truly mature and ensure you will not repeat the same behaviors. Every other ban appeal has been denied. You were on a last chance when you were banned last, therefore I see no reason to reinstate you. My opinion is that the ban should continue to be enforced. Waiting for other staff to opine on the situation and make a decision.

[PengBunny]

Reviewing your ban, it seems as if you are under a permaban for multiple offenses. Furthermore, the ban is six months old. I doubt that is enough time to truly mature and ensure you will not repeat the same behaviors. Every other ban appeal has been denied. You were on a last chance when you were banned last, therefore I see no reason to reinstate you. My opinion is that the ban should continue to be enforced. Waiting for other staff to opine on the situation and make a decision.

I disagree I have recently played with and talked to Concobe and he has matured. I think he should get another chance.

[OctoGamer]

i don't think he should be given another chance. you've just fucked up to many times.

[Witchdoctor1]

Reviewing your ban, it seems as if you are under a permaban for multiple offenses. Furthermore, the ban is six months old. I doubt that is enough time to truly mature and ensure you will not repeat the same behaviors. Every other ban appeal has been denied. You were on a last chance when you were banned last, therefore I see no reason to reinstate you. My opinion is that the ban should continue to be enforced. Waiting for other staff to opine on the situation and make a decision.

I disagree I have recently played with and talked to Concobe and he has matured. I think he should get another chance.

That may be so, but to overturn a permaban, I would need far more than this to consider throwing in my support. I respect your stance and, depending on the opinions of the other staff, would take it into consideration should I be asked to partake in any decision.

[Akomine]

I'm with Witch, I want to be a little more convinced that he's changed.

Peng, you vouching for him is new. Last appeal of his you said you didn't see him keeping true to his word.
Do you think if he came back to VC, he'd be a half-decent player?


I'm willing to vote in favour of an unban on a last-chance agreement if he is only allowed to use ONE account, no alts, and only if a few more staff agree.

I'm always interested to see if people can change their ways, and I really hate being disappointed when they get banned again, as he has been. I'm so unsure, I find it so hard to think that someone who logs in with 10 accounts to bother someone is the kind of person who suddenly isn't an asshole anymore and can be a cool player.

[PengBunny]

Yes I think he would be a half decent player, after talking to him since his last ban appeal, he has shown me atleast, that he is different and I think ready to come back to VC.

[Akomine]

In that case, I will personally vote yes if at least 3 other staff are willing to do the same, peng is the first.

[Airbongo]

I vote yes too, give him a chance.

[OctoGamer]

i'm keeping my vote at no, after his last fuck up. who comes on with like 10 different alts just to harass someone?  i also find it hard to believe that hes changed considering he got banned after multiple appeals.

[Witchdoctor1]

So, have we reached a consensus on this?

[OctoGamer]

i still personally say no, but i'll leave the verdict to someone else

[Akomine]

So, have we reached a consensus on this?

No, seems mixed. I was personally waiting for 3 yes votes and I've only seen 2.

[Witchdoctor1]

So, have we reached a consensus on this?

No, seems mixed. I was personally waiting for 3 yes votes and I've only seen 2.

So we have 2 no, 2 yes and a bunch of "I haven't bothered to read this yet"

[OctoGamer]

Verdict: Appeal, Denied, we had a vote and 50% said no, 25% said yes and 25% abstained. you cannot appeal again for 2 months.

Topic locked.